News & Opinion
Branding Talks
Good Stuff
Trybunał za wzmocnieniem ochrony praw autorskich w Polsce
O społecznym sensie prawa z Profesorem Andrzejem Zollem rozmawia Judyta Papp
   Oct 30, 2016
- Judyta Papp talks with Professor Andrzej Zoll about social sense of the law
Judyta Papp: What are the optimal relations between the legal system and the political system in a law-abiding, democratic state?
Andrzej Zoll: The State system depends on the legal regulations. The question is rather, what is the relation between the public authority and the legal order. You can put it this way: if the legal order is used by the public authority only to exercise power - as an instrument for achieving the political goals of the party, then we are dealing with an authoritarian system, the system that often takes a totalitarian form. On the other hand, if the public authority does not treat the legal order only as an instrument of exercising power, but primarily as a way to limit this power - then the legal system protects the state against autocratic designs of the authorities. Therefore, if the law is, so to speak, above the public authority, then we have the system of a democratic law-governed state, or at least a law-governed state, because as whether it is truly democratic it depends on many other factors. The history shows us law-governed states that were not democratic. Take, for example, 19th-century Prussia. Especially in its first period, this state did not have much in common with democracy, but it was ruled by the law, which was above the state authority and those authorities were bound by that law. Another important issue is: in what form will this law be established. If the law is established in the democratic form, i.e. it is the majority of the society that decides on the law in force, and the society elects, in free and democratic elections, their representatives who establish the law, then we can talk about a democratic law-governed state. In such a state, the legal order limits the state authority in the public interest, in compliance with the principle of legality. This principle is expressed in Article 7 of the Polish Constitution of 1997: The organs of public authority shall function on the basis of, and within the limits of, the law. Which means that the public authority does not have the freedom of action. In this situation, we can say that if there is no specific regulation, no legal restrictions for the public authority, then in this case, the public authority may act guided by its own discretion.
JP: You can’t decree everything, which means that in this situation, the public authority can do whatever it wants?
AZ: No, because the public authority is equipped only with powers which derive from the legal norm, that is - the law must allow a particular action. Every action of the public authority must be supported by the law. For example, if we are summoned to appear before a public officer to make a statement or give explanations, in a law-abiding state such a summons begins as follows: Pursuant to article this and that, you are hereby summoned to appear in this office. The authority must refer to the legal basis of its action, expressed in the power to summon a citizen, and the powers to perform any other activity. Because, as I must stress again, the public authority is not free to act, it must have the powers designated by the law, and it can act only within the limits of those powers.
JP: Mazowiecki, Kuroń, Turowicz - authorities of Solidarność - once claimed: so much freedom as responsibility. How can citizens make officials of the judiciary system and ruling politicians guarantee justice, security, freedom and democracy? What may ordinary citizens do?
AZ: Citizens have a very important tool in the hands - elections. Here comes the matter of responsibility for elections. The fact that we are a society which ignores (i must admit it) this ultimate act of making decisions about its fate and does not participate in elections - is our huge loss. We claim for a democratic state while the essence of democracy are public, free elections and responsible voting. If in the most important elections in the last several decades (organized in June 1989), only 62 percent of people cast their votes, it means that rest of the society did not care what happened in Poland and with Poland.
JP: At the time, you could not have expected a massive civic attitude...
AZ: This does not justify such a low turnout. It was known what the dramatic and unequal fight was about. Many people simply used the fact that mandatory voting was abolished and just gave up. Such a civic attitude is confirmed by the fact that the low turnout was higher than in all the following elections - already in the free, democratic state.
JP: What is the reason why citizens do not want be involved?
AZ: As I mentioned, we do not feel obliged and responsible.
JP: Or maybe they decided that they had nothing to choose from as no party was credible for them?
AZ: But in 1989 there was neither Civic Platform nor PiS (Law and Justice)
JP: I mean the recent elections.
AZ: You may not want to vote for the Platform or PiS but respectable citizens of a serious country should take care to create a formation which they would trust and which would represent them. Citizens are equipped with a strong tool for making decisions about their fate - why don't they use them?
JP: Or why do they use them in such an irresponsible manner?
AZ: This is exactly the point. After all, the essence and point of a civic society is self-organization.
JP: No authorities or competent leaders whom they could trust?
AZ: This is not exactly the point. Who forms political groups? I am not a Kukiz enthusiast but his movement is a typical result of a “bottom-up” initiative. A result infected with no responsibility for the choice made by his supporters. And here we return to the starting point: false self-awareness, social alienation, to civic immaturity of too many Poles - regardless of their status. We do not learn from our mistakes and we do not want to learn from good solutions. We are not convinced...
JP: That something depends on us
AZ: .. that so much depends on us.

Polish version ©
Photo by Judyta Papp

Add Comment

•  The quick or the dead
On June 14, 1946, the United States representative to the Atomic Energy Commission
•  Lack of respect for its Judiciary
Media release by the President of the Judicial Conference of Australia 18th October 2016.
•  The U.S. to pivot to Indonesia
As America entertained itself with the vital questions of whether Hillary Clinton's
•  Arabization of Islam in Indonesia
It is a sign of the violent age we live in that there is a website in
•  What Putin Should say at the UN
Today, Russian President Vladimir Putin will address the United Nations General
•  Turkey and the Kurds
Exactly 95 years ago, the Ottoman Empire came to an end. On August 10, 1920
•  Iraq is not Iraq anymore
WASHINGTON - So, this is where we are in America today: the wealthy son of a
•  Pope on Pr. Abbas - The angel of peace
Pope Francis on Saturday referred to Mahmoud Abbas as 'an angel of peace'
•  Merkel calls For EU unity
German Chancellor Angela Merkel rejects Russia' breach of international law in
•  Soros sounds wake-up call on ukraine
First it was Jimmy Carter, and now it’s George Soros-Obama’s 'no stupid stuff'
•  EU's course: losing Ukraine
It took the shooting down of a Malaysian commercial aircraft by pro-Russian
•  How EU and USA discuss commerce
The trade agreement negotiations between the EU and USA are being handled
•  EU with Ukraine, Georgia, Moldova
The European Union signed free-trade and political cooperation agreements
•  Ukraine elects a new leader
The US takes a 'wait and see' approach after Ukraine elects a new president
•  The great Chancellor speech
German chancellor Angela Merkel has warned that Moscow's annexation of
•  Poland and the eurozone
Professor Marek Belka President of the National Bank of Poland comments on
•  Unconventional monetary policy
The European Central Bank ready to fight deflation keeps close eye on euro
•  Ukraine demands, Russia supplies
Before we get too far in this subject, I want all of the readers to understand
•  New laws in Ukraine
A peaceful anti-government protest in Kyiv descended into chaos when clashes
•  Poland among the wealthiest
According to both our and international calculations, it is a plausible target.
•  The Maidan of victory?
In the past, Maidan was a dwelling place of forest workers, a place were felled
•  UK in sustained recovery
How many of us are aware that Poland - after more than a hundred years
•  Our independent. But what?
On 14th October 2013, the Royal Swedish Academy of Sciences awarded the
•  Nobel Prize in Economy awarded
How many of us are aware that Poland - after more than a hundred years
•  Germany to receive gas from Qatar
On Wednesday, the German concern E.ON signed a five-year-long contract for the
•  Syria - a step from war
•  Poland on intervention in Syria
•  Syria and oily priorities

For advertising contact us at:

© 2019 Judyta Papp Ltd., All rights reserved.